Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Test Drive - Peugeot 207 Rally 1.6THP 150 Review

What a brilliant way of selling the 207!
I've tested the 2009 207 rally (Portuguese edition) and I really loved it. By that time I was quite used to it's brother the 207 1.6Hdi sport, so switching to this was very refreshing and a true recognition of what I was suspecting from the other peugeot.
Where the other peugeot seemed too high and clumsy, this seems glued to the ground and very agile. The engine is another good thing, the hdi just doesn't have the punch for this chassis, but this?!this turns the car into a real rocket.

It's a fun car to have. It's so honest that it even has 4 seats (instead of the 5claimmed seats you'll find on the hdi).
It's 1.6 Petrol High Pressure Turbo with direct fuel injection is just a ball. It's the same engine from the mini and it's a clear BMW/PSA joint venture with a lot of technology very well thought out. It's elastic and very alive.
It's 150Bhp feel strong ans solid, making the car feel a lot lighter than the hdi 207.
Again, in this car you'll find a 5 speed gearbox. As expected it's high quality and very precise, but the brilliant engine and the car's dynamics will make you want to have another gear. It's easy to reach ignition cut-out in 5th and if there was a 6th gear, the car would be a lot more flexible. I wouldn't even change the 5 first gears ratios, witch are quite perfect...just add a 6th.

The chassis is very competent and (the best thing) tail happy. Lift-off over-steer on demand with a natural and composed let-go and re-grip. Even while driving hard on a bumpy road, it will grab the front and loose the rear. Clearly signed by Peugeot/Citroen and it's competitive heritage.
Unlike the standard 207, this doesn't feel like a minivan... it's much more agile and the confidence level allows you to explore further than the standard car.
It's a car you can unsettle, drift into a corner with inertia and chassis composure, and pull it out under acceleration. The thp is fast and responsive enough to allow acceleration "steering". This car reminds me of the Mk2 Honda civic Type-r with it's EP3 chassis - it's close to the minivan looks of it's brothers but still much more agile and composed.

A bad thing on this car was the original tire choice (Pzero's). I reckon that a decent set of tires would allow for a better handling in both dry and wet.

The steering is precise but could have a smaller wheel with heavier feel. It's feed back is improved from the standard 207, but the big wheel spoils things a bit.

The pedals are a bit too soft, but the gearbox operation has just the right weigh.

The driving position is good and the standard bucket seats are a wonder. Both comfortable and with excellent lateral holding and support. Probably the best off the line seat I've seen in an peugeot.

The build quality is far better than the 2007 hdi 207. It's clear that peugeot are implementing the plan-do-check-act.

Overall I give this car a very good rating. Something to buy and hold on to as it's a limited series edition. I would probably spend some money down the line fitting a quaife 6speed sequential gearbox and an LSD, but that's it, it's brilliant enough from factory.








Test Drive - Peugeot 207 Hdi 110 Sport Review

I've been testing this car for some time now.
I've been intermittently using it from it's 20.000Km to it's sale last month at 54.000Km.
It was a 2007 207 model... the brand new one back then, and as every new model that created a big leap in innovation electronics, it had to be serviced recurrently during the first year. From ECU remaps to onboard computer firmware updates, this one had it all.
I guess that this is where price brand shows up. When I brought the MK2 Volvo S40 in late 2006, the car had innovative electronics all-round, and though it's been issued service firmware updates, mine just remained with version 1.0 while I've owned it (until last year)... and no glitches at all that could be noticeable.
This one however is a hole different thing. From Switching lights, wind-shield wipers and water mid night all alone in the garage, all the way to not turning them on while needed. A friend that had the car parked for a week while on a trip, arrived to find the battery drained together with all the wind-shield cleaning water...so it's fair to assume that it's been doing that for the entire week until no more battery power was available.
Again, it's a known issue with most French cars. Innovate in electronics and you should wait a full year until you buy the car, or be prepared to service it recurrently until debugging is all done (I blame Microsoft for this.... until they appeared on the earth's surface, no one would sell beta products as final versions, let alone charge for it... now it seems standard practice all over).

Having solved the problems the car became a very enjoyable possession.
It's 1.6 diesel engine is robust and quite elastic. And it's said to have 110bhp (in this version) but it clearly doesn't feel so. It feels heavy whenever you need to accelerate. There is a trick however that let's off a tip on how this car is electronically managed: instead of flooring your foot, use the cruse control and set it to 220km/h (witch will never ever happen as it will struggle to go beyond 190 and I've never seen it go beyond 205km/h). I would guess that the on-board computer requests an over-boost that your feet and the gas pedal can't do. So in truth, the car will accelerate faster if you don't step on the gas.
It's not brilliant in terms of economy, making an average of 5.6lts/100km. I don't find this a good average since it's a diesel and it's main purpose is to be economical... and if it was an 1.4 tdi with PD technology on it, it would do almost half as that with the same torque and little less power.
This car, as many other Peugeot, had a 5 speed gearbox. Feels like you're driving a vintage. Don't get me wrong, the feel and sync of the gearbox if good. It's very good indeed and if for some reason you grind during shift, YOU are to blame, as the box is very precise. It does however miss a gear and I feel that with a diesel it's a MUST in this time and age.

The chassis is very competent and (the best thing) tail happy. Lift-off over-steer on demand with a natural and composed let-go and re-grip. Even while driving hard on a bumpy road, it will grab the front and loose the rear. Clearly signed by Peugeot/Citroen and it's competitive heritage. It would be so much better car if only it wasn't designed as a minivan.
This car is very high. It's not a minivan, it's a car, and that means that there are at least 10cm of excessive hight that shouldn't be there as it's not used at all. That, together with a comfortable suspension, makes the car feel strange, and thought you can abuse it more, you don't feel the confidence to do that with all that wobbling.
It's suspension is also very sensitive to it's bushing maintenance condition. This unit suffered a lot during it's first 30.000km as it was daily driven through a road under construction...that took it's part in the premature deterioration of what is (on purpose to my view) an already too sensitive element. You see car makers insist on placing rubber between steel joints. In competition however they use polyurethane. The result it that every 50.000km, you have to change your entire suspension bushings because the rubber is all cut and falling apart, allowing uncontrolled suspension parts movement and altering angles leading to bad handling, edgy bump steer and excessive tire wear. WHY don't they come with polyurethane from factory!?!?!?!
Still, this chassis is EXTREMELY sensitive to bushing conditions. Causing more bump steer and wobbling that I thought a car with this weight would.


The steering is precise but could have a smaller wheel with heavier feel. It lacks some feed back but I'm blaming the soft Michelin tires for 50% of that numbness. Careful with the bushings here... the steering will struggle to return from full lock under breaking if your bushings are in bad condition.

The pedals are a bit too soft, but the gearbox operation has just the right weigh.

The driving position is good and the seats are competent enough for a fast drive... as long as you don't push it too hard and go Scandinavian flips all over, you should end up seated where you started.

The build quality is not brilliant. It's clear that it's not a design flaw, but rather assembly line one. For instance, this car had the driver seat with 2 loose screws, a rear right light unit with a poorly soldered earth-grounding connector (causing the electronic diagnostics system to beep every other road bump), a poorly screwed rear bumper and almost all the wheel inside covers started dropping after 30.000kms. Nothing difficult to solve or complex, but still irritating and the driver's seat slack from bend to bend was a scary flaw.


Overall I give this car a good rating. As it's enjoyable and easy to live with, once you solve the classical new car problems. However, if in the need of choosing another car like this, I would go the Ford Fiesta way... same engine brilliant chassis, far better built and less twitchy... and that's exactly what I recommended to 4 people.



Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Test Drive - Volvo V60 1.6D review

I've just tested the brand new V60 from Volvo. Did I had an already made opinion? yup. Still I was extremely surprised.
First I only concluded it was a 1.6 unit after going into 4th gear. Until then it just looked like a dammed 2.0 diesel with a torque limiter for lower gears.
having owned a volvo s40 mk2 2.0 diesel and a s60 mk1 2.4 d5 diesel, I got used to either have a normal diesel masked as a brute one with a distinct under boost power surge from the 2.0 diesel, and the much more powerfull d5 looking as a dammed kitten with a very linear power delivery.
Having sad that, I'll add that the 2.0 is peugeot's hdi 136ps -340nm unit... just like this one is the peugeot sourced 1.6 110ps hdi. And I've driven the 207 1.6hdi 110ps and it's a smaller car and it sure feels like a 1.6 diesel. This 1.6 volvo however feels a lot different.
I don't know if volvo is electronically boosting the 1.6 unit under lower revs (opposite to cutting the torque curve like they do in the d5)... but certain feels like that. The gears seam quite normal, so it probably isn't a gear ratio tweak, leaving the engine management and over-boost as the next logical explanation.
The car feels as alive as it feels soft on the power delivery through most of the engine's usable rev range. The sound tuning is also very nice... under power it roars gently, making it look like a v8 engine cruising sound. Very very good for a diesel and even better for such a small one.

Driving position and seats are, as usual with volvo, very good and it's easy to adjust the seat to find your driving position. Steering weight is good and feedback is also high enough to make it sporty. The tires on this unit were thin-walled-comfort-oriented and that probably ruined the feedback. However, although inferior to the volvo s40 steering feedback I was used to (hard compound, thick-wall sport tires on 17inch rims) it does feel a lot (A LOOOOT) better than the old S60. It doesn't feel excessively soft.
Both brake and gas pedals are well sorted out and have a good feeling, however the clutch is very over servo'd and a bit too long.
Gear knob is ergonomically well designed and placed, but the rubber joints on the knob axle should be harder... it's just to soft and if cornering hard while changing gear, it's easy to miss the correct one.

Driving the car is an excellent experience. The chassis is good and competent allowing for either under-steer if you accelerate while turning harder and harder, but does so with plenty warning and control. The best thing about the chassis is the over-steer and turn-in. It allows you to lift-off and turn a bit sharper in the middle of the bends without recurring to inertia flips and chassis de-compensation... and being like that as a natural feature, makes it easier to use it in a more efficient way. You just grab the bend, use the lift-off and sharp blow turn-in, let it slide gently and power it thought the apex.
I can clearly understand why the commercial has a V60 instead of the saloon s60 and a driver making it slide aground an empty warehouse lot. This thing feels more agile than an megane... and it's a lot bigger and heavier. The car feels more light than my old mk2 S40 and that is a huge improvement over the first s60. The old one felt heavy and too much comfort oriented to allow a decent drive... driving the old one let-me as disappointed as the 5series bmw did.
This new one however IS very agile. The car doesn't feel big or heavy and it certainly doesn't feel like a van.


The center console is a bit too bloated for my like and the new buttons, thow pleasant to touch and in lighting, are not as elegant as the ones I remember from the S40. Honestly... I liked the old one better. The displays (console displays and speedometer/rev displays) are better than the old ones.



However I like the central console display, I think that the speedometer and rev-counter center-less needle is a bit to copy-of-mercedesbenz....and i don't like-it. For the cost that unit provably takes building, volvo could have fit an amoled 14x9 inch full digital display and go the lexus lfa way :S
Space is very generous like every volvo station-wagon has been since forever.
Overall I strongly recommend a test-drive with some serious cornering on some serious B-roads, if you want to find out just how good that car really is. If you stick to the standard go-around-the-parking-lot test-drive, you'll never ever going to get the best thing from that car...it's agility.

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Having a DNA base is no warranty of success


1%. That's the difference between human DNA and Chimp's DNA. That's the difference between Claudia Shiffer and a hairy smelly dumb human lookalike. Ok , they have better strength, but they don't have the brains to cope.
Some cars suffer the same problem.
I knew I hated the new mini jeep-a-like. I hated so immediately after watching it the first time, that I never ever took time to look at it again.
The other day however, I was staring right across the street and I had an epiphany.
The design is still there, the mini beautiful curves and lines still manage to survive the otherwise qualifiable as a brute rape. And the it hit me! It's that 1% thing. Same DNA, same base lines spoiled by horrible 1% DNA rape.
Is it good? probably! It's has BMW DNA... is it beautiful? Hell no... it's that 1% thing, you know?
1% that transforms this...


into this...

even the kids with their (arguably) bad taste in cars seem to faint in agony!


The only good news is that Hollywood will have an easier job next time they throw some down the subway stairs...these should overcome the down-way easier, and if they crash, no one will ever be bothered with the looks....maybe they get even better.

On the other hand the same DNA without the 1% chimp mutation will allow for some beautiful cars...
...and some gloriously gorgeous ones, like the roadster: